Every article addressed to the editorial staff will be selected through the Initial Review process by the Editorial Board. Then, the article will be sent to the Bebestari Partner / peer reviewer and will be entered into the next selection by the Blind Review Process. After that, the article will be returned to the author for revision. This process takes one month for the maximum time. In each script, the Bebestari Partner / peer reviewer will be assessed from a substantial and technical aspect. The Bebestari partner / peer reviewer who collaborates with Al-Tazkiah is an expert in the field of Counseling Guidance, Psychology, and Islamic Psychotherapy and surrounding issues. They are experienced in the management of prestigious journals and publications that are spread across national and abroad.

All texts submitted are read by editorial staff. Manuscripts that are evaluated by editors to be incompatible with journal criteria are rejected immediately without external review. Manuscripts that are considered potentially interesting for our readers are sent to a double reviewer. The editors then make decisions based on the reviewer's recommendations of several possibilities: rejected, revised required, or accepted.

The editor has the right to decide which manuscripts to submit to the journal must be published.

Review Process:

The author submits the manuscript
Editor's evaluation (some manuscripts were rejected or returned before the review process)
Blind the peer review process
Editor's Decision
Confirm to the author